Sen. Chris Van Hollen with feds and union reps

Feds, unions continue push to make deferred payroll tax optional

Feds and their unions are pushing back against one COVID-era policy billed as “help”—but that seems, to some, sure to end up hurting.

That policy? Payroll tax deferral for feds, a four-month-long program announced by the White House back in August, across federal agencies—and subsequently implemented as a mandatory process.

The administration bills this as COVID “relief”—as putting money into feds’ pockets in a time of crisis and cash into the American economy at a time of reduced consumer demand. For now, the vast majority of feds—just about all executive branch feds earning less than $4,000 per pay period—no longer have their payroll taxes deducted on paydays.

But, hey, there’s a big catch: Come next year, they will have to pay it all back—thousands of dollars! So, amid a rising chorus of federal employees’ complaints that the program is bound to cause trouble later, some in Congress have been moved to act.

The Surprise Taxes Act, a bill sponsored by Sen. Chris Van Hollen (D.-Md.), would compel the administration to gain the consent of each fed—with an “opt-in”—before deferring any more payroll tax, and forcing them to take yet another loan in effect from the government.

Federal unions have slammed the White House policy, and are urging passage of the bill.

“This payroll tax deferral plan is nothing but a temporary loan program and federal employees deserve to choose whether they want to participate,” National Treasury Employees Union President Tony Reardon said on Oct. 9. “We appreciate Sen. Van Hollen and his growing list of cosponsors for looking out for workers who want to protect themselves from the burdens of higher taxes and smaller paychecks come January.” 

Reardon noted that both the legislative and judicial arms of government were able to opt out—and they did. “[Employees] in the executive branch were forced into it without sufficient explanation of when the deferrals would start, how employees could calculate whether they were subject to it, and how the deferred taxes will be collected by the government next year,” the union’s statement said.

Another major fed union—the American Federation of Government Employees—likewise blasted the tax deferral policy from its early days—and, in its initial press release on the issue, called it  “Trump’s Social Security tax scam”.

The National Federation of Federal Employees also trashed the policy, similarly calling it a “payroll tax scam,” and pressed for it to be abandoned.

“President Trump and the treasury secretary made fools of themselves by issuing this order and guidance,” NFFE President Randy Erwin said in a statement on the issue. “Even the business community and the U.S. Chamber of Commerce believe this is a dumb idea.”

NTEU’s Reardon added that those feds who might want to continue to defer their payroll taxes will be allowed to do so. “Under Sen. Van Hollen’s bill, federal employees who want to participate in the deferral would be able to continue doing so, which is how the federal government should have structured the program in the first place,” Reardon stated.  

Reader comments

Thu, Oct 15, 2020

I wouldn't be so sure that it will be waived. There's no official announcement of that is there.

Wed, Oct 14, 2020

Hey, the POTUS has stated that all of the payback will be waived once he is re-elected, so VOTE!

Wed, Oct 14, 2020

If Congress wants to make fed employees happy(as I'm sure EVERY fed employee will be considering this issue when they go to the voting booth next month), they need to FORGIVE the debt; that is, NO ONE who was forced to participate should have to pay the debt next year.

Wed, Oct 14, 2020

this is a scam and we should have the option to opt-out

Wed, Oct 14, 2020

Yes; I would like to opt-out. As an employee, I should be able to choose whether or not I want to participate. I am extremely disappointed that this was forced upon us.

Show All Comments

Please post your comments here. Comments are moderated, so they may not appear immediately after submitting. We will not post comments that we consider abusive or off-topic.

Please type the letters/numbers you see above.

2021 Digital Almanac

Stay Connected

Latest Forum Posts

Ask the Expert

Have a question regarding your federal employee benefits or retirement?

Submit a question